Personal Lines Claims

Report your claim directly, or contact us.

The industry’s leading insurance companies.

For your convenience, you may directly report your claim to your insurance carrier by calling them directly or visiting their website. Don’t worry; you won’t lose our personal touch! You may still reach out to our Reagan Companies Claim Department with any claim related questions.

A Central Insurance

Claims

Report Claim

Notes

800-234-6926

Adirondack Insurance Exchange

Claims

Report Claim

Notes

877-629-8003

Chubb Insurance

Claims

Report Claim

Notes

800-252-4670

Cincinnati Insurance Companies

Claims

Report Claim

Notes

877-242-2544
Glass Only: 877-588-4527

Dryden Mutual Insurance Company

Claims

Report Claim

Notes

Phone: 800-782-0154
Phone: 800-556-5802 (Nights/Weekends)

Encompass Insurance

Claims

Report Claim

Notes

800-588-7400

Erie & Niagara

Claims

Report Claim

Notes

800-234-9876

Foremost Insurance Group

Claims

Report Claim

Notes

800-274-7865 (Auto)
800-527-3907(All policies except auto)

Hagerty

Claims

Report Claim

Notes

800-385-0274

Hanover Insurance Group

Claims

Report Claim

Notes

800-628-0250
800-955-7668 (Glass Only)

Infinity Insurance

Claims

Report Claim

Notes

800-334-1661

National Flood Insurance Plan

Notes

800-767-4341

National General Insurance

Claims

Report Claim

Notes

800-325-1088

NYCM Insurance

Claims

Report Claim

Notes

800-234-6926

Preferred Mutual

Claims

Report Claim

Notes

800-333-7642

Progressive

Claims

Report Claim

Notes

800-776-4737

Safeco Insurance

Notes

800-332-3226
877-762-3101 (Roadside Assistance)

Security Mutual Insurance

Notes

800-822-1232

The Hartford

Claims

Report Claim

Notes

800-243-5860
800-892-8484 (Glass Only)

The Main Street America Group

Claims

Report Claim

Notes

877-425-2467
800-887-5944 (Glass Only)

Travelers

Claims

Report Claim

Notes

800-252-4633

Utica National Insurance Group

Claims

Report Claim

Notes

800-216-1420